You've seen the excerpts from Mike Singletary's season-ending press conference. And, now, here is the Q&A session in its entirety (courtesy of the fine folks in the 49ers' public-relations department who transcribed every syllable).

Mike, can you talk about your offensive philosophy and why that philosophy might have been at odds with what Mike Martz wanted to do?

Singletary: "My offensive philosophy is more of a traditional one, more of a run to pass, when it really comes right down to it, sometimes you have to pass more, sometimes you have to run more, depending on the clock situation, depending on the score. But if I'm going to go into the game, my philosophy is to run a little bit more than passing and hopefully have a balance, 50-50, but the most important thing for me is to be able to run. You have to know that you can run the football. I'm not trying to outsmart anybody, I'm not trying to be a magician, we are playing football and we need to be able to run the football."

 

And was that basically the reason that you decided to dismiss Mike Martz?

Singletary: "'No, it was not. Really, the bottom line was it's just a difference in philosophy, it's as simple as that.  I think Mike Martz's philosophy works. I think it works. I think obviously it works, he's been very successful with it. I think everywhere he's gone he's had success. I know that we have to have a long-term solution for that position at the offensive coordinator and philosophy-wise going forward, just did not feel that the fit was there."

 

So did you not consider Mike Martz a long-term solution?

Singletary: "No, I did not."

 

And why is that?

Singletary: "Because our philosophies are different."

 

When you say long-term deal, maybe you are looking at a younger guy who isn't...

Singletary: "No, I'm not looking at a younger guy. It has nothing to do with age. It's only philosophy."

 

Mike, I don't know what you mean by philosophy is different...

Singletary: "When I say philosophy, this is what I mean. If I'm looking at a coordinator and that coordinator likes to do more of a...basically a four wideout, five wideout, throw a little bit here. Dunk and dink here. That's different than what I'm looking for. If there's an offensive coordinator that likes to have a traditional I-back, split the tight end out, move people around a little bit more and really just kind of wing it here, throw it there. That's not what I'm looking for. That's a different branch of the West Coast Offense, they are different branches of the West Coast Offense. Then there's the stretch offense where you are going down the field, which is more of Coach Martz's offense, I'm going to throw it down field, but it's throw it downfield often rather than running the football and there are different branches of that. I am in the mode of more of a traditional style of offense, very much like the style that used to be here when Coach Bill Walsh was here, but in a different mindset. I want to know I have the ability to know that I can run the ball. I want to have the ability to know that I can impose my will on the defense. I want to know that in the fourth quarter, I can run the football. I want to know that when they put eight people in the box, I can still run the football, if I want to. I don't want to make it seem like I am a three yards and a cloud of dust kind of guy because I'm not. I am very much into innovation. I am very much into motion, moving people around, I am very much into that, but when everything settles and we need to control the football, I need to know that I can run the football and I'm not trying to do anything fancy at that time. I want to run the football."

 

Is that philosophy born in your playing days, that is when you were a linebacker, was that the type of offenses you found were most difficult to stop?

Singletary: "I find that today. You look around the league today, I think those teams that are successful year in and year out, when it really gets down to it, they are saying, 'You know what, it's been nice playing you, it's been nice to do this, but right now we are going to take the game over and we are going to run the football. To me those are the teams that are going to be successful year in and year out and not going to go out of style. You have to be able to do that. It's as simple to me as blocking and tackling. Some teams do it different, they have different philosophies, that just happens to my philosophy or our philosophy."

 

Do you have the offensive line to play this kind of football that you speak of?

Singletary: "Yes sir."

 

Mike, two years ago this team had an inexperience offensive coordinator struggle. Would you want to go to that, or are you looking at guys that have run offenses, have called plays in the NFL before?

Singletary: "I want to do what gives us a chance to win. I think sometimes you can get a coach that has a lot of experience and it doesn't work. I think the most important thing is that we find the right fit. Obviously, I'd like to have a guy that's done it before and has been successful at it and there are some guys out there that have that, but I think the most important thing right now is we sit down and talk to that person, that offensive coordinator, whoever that is, it's important that they have that factor in them that understands, when we talk about being able to impose your will on another team's defense, being able to control the game when you want to control the game. Being able to control the clock when you want to control the clock, you can do that. It's not something that, 'Well we can't do that, we've got to do some other things,' that will get us in trouble, don't want to do that. I want to be able to do that, to me that is important and it's an important formula to win consistently in my mind."

 

Have you made contact with any candidates so far?

Singletary: "Right now we're just gathering information, gathering all the data that we can and being prepared to make the move forward when necessary."

 

Mike do you have a list of people in your head that you would like to see win the job?

Singletary: "Um, yes."

 

How long's the list?

Singletary: "Right now, it's pretty long, but it will shorten up real soon."

 

Mike, this team has drifted around from offensive philosophy to offensive philosophy, how do you....I think you want continuity, you get the right person, but how do you keep that philosophy in place that will sustain the team rather than what it's been going through?

Singletary: "I certainly understand what you are saying, 'You've got to be kidding me, we've got to go through another coordinator?' Yes, I think sometimes you have to take a step back, in order to go forward. The only thing that I can say is, we will find the right guy. We will find the right person that is the right fit going forward and that person will understand the philosophy and hopefully we can have them awhile and get the continuity that we need. We have to go fast this offseason and the learning and everything else and we'll do the things that we need to do to get our players up to speed and ready to go, but I just think, I don't want a band-aid, I don't want a patch, I don't want a compromise. I want to find that person. You've got to find that person and we will find them. He's out there. We'll find them and once we find that person, we've got to move. We've got to go, we've got to act, we've got to respond, then we've got to move."

 

Do you have a timetable given that, when you'd like to have a...

Singletary: "Yesterday, yesterday."

 

Realistically...

Singletary: "I'm saying yesterday, realistically, as soon as possible. As soon as possible."

 

When Mike Nolan was hired he was given control of the 53-man roster, do you have any...

Singletary: "Yes, sir I do."

 

You do?

Singletary: "Yes sir."

 

Do you have any say on the 53-man roster?

Singletary: "Yes sir, I do."

 

Was that a part of the negotiation on Monday, or did you demand that...

Singletary: "I didn't really have to demand anything. I think Scot McCloughan and I are working very well together. I think we'll move forward together. I think it's very important that we have a compromising spirit between us. I am certainly not in the spirit of, 'Hey, I'm doing this. I want this. This is my...' because I'm trying to teach a team to work together and compromise and understand what one means. So Scot and I, we're going to have to lead that way and be an example that way. And, to me, that's what it's all about."

 

Do you report to Scot McCloughan or to Jed York?

Singletary: "I report to Scot."

 

How does that work if you control the 53-man roster, if you want to draft somebody and he wants to draft somebody else...

Singletary: "Compromise. Compromise. I think it's all about compromise. Hopefully, you don't get into the situation where, 'Well, it's my draft choice versus this,' and all this other kind of - to me, even if you had a situation like that: I'm in control of this, you're in control of that. If we're going to win, and I'm standing over here saying, 'You know what? This is, I'm standing on this. This is mine,' we're not going to win. We've lost already. So, I'm very confident in the fact that Scot and I will be able to come together and work together, and compromise and respect each other enough to agree, and agree to disagree and move on. To me, that's what it's all about. It's all about communication. It's all about trust. It's all about all of those things. I am confident that we'll do just fine."

 

Scot McCloughan and Mike Nolan talked a lot about the 'trigger' last season. Do you have the trigger?

Singletary: "Trigger? I don't - I'm not going to get fancy with words. I don't really know what that means."

 

I think final say.

Singletary: "Pardon?"

 

Final say.

Singletary: "Final say. I'll put it this way: I know what I have control over. What does that mean? Whatever Scot has control over, what does that mean? He can fire me? I've got a job to do. If I'm not doing that job correctly, I'll fire myself. That's the kind of person I am. If I'm not doing the job, if I feel that job is over my head, I'll fire myself. I'm going to walk off myself. The most important thing to me, in all honesty, is this: It's about the team. It's about getting everything out of this team that we can. It's not about Scot and it's not about me. It's about us coming together and understanding we're trying to build something really, really important. And, if either of us get in the way, it means we're not smart enough to have that job."

 

Will there be any other changes to your staff other than offensive coordinator?

Singletary: "No."

 

Everybody else stays?

Singletary: "Yes."

 

Does that mean the offensive coordinator you hire will not be able to make changes and bring his own people in?

Singletary: "Normally, the offensive coordinator that comes in, he has a person that he likes to have with him, and normally that's a quarterbacks coach. That's the flexibility that we have allotted him, whoever that is. So, we move forward with that."

 

So he can bring in his own quarterbacks coach?

Singletary: "Yes."

 

What happens to Ted Tollner?

Singletary: "He can bring in the - no. Well, I'm sorry, go ahead and ask the question."

 

Are you talking about an offensive assistant?

Singletary: "Offensive assistant, quarterback coach, whatever that might be. Whatever that is that he needs, that person, he can have that flexibility to bring him with him."

 

OK, so my question would be now, Ted Tollner is the quarterbacks coach. How does that affect him?

Singletary: "Ted Tollner got let go yesterday."

 

He did?

Singletary: "Yes, he did."

 

Were there any other coaches who were let go?

Singletary: "Mike Martz. Ted Tollner. Tony Nathan."

 

Is Adam Gase still on  staff?

Singletary: "Adam Gase is still on staff."

 

What's your timetable - will you wait to fill those other positions when the new offensive coordinator comes in?

Singletary: "We'll just fill them at the appropriate times."

 

As of right now, the coaches you do have on your staff right now, unless they leave on their own volition, do you plan to proceed with them?

Singletary: "Absolutely."

 

No other changes planned other than the three just mentioned?

Singletary: "No other coaches leaving our staff, other than what we have right here."

 

Why were Ted Tollner and Tony Nathan let go?

Singletary: "Well, because we felt moving forward - I felt making the decision right now that would help us get to where we needed to go. I needed to make those decisions. So, that's why he was let go."

 

Have you talked to Scott Linehan about being your offensive coordinator?

Singletary: "I have not."

 

Is he someone that you've talked about internally?

Singletary: "At this time, we've got a lot of people on the list. But, I don't want to single out anyone at this time that we've talked to or haven't talked to or considered or whatever. But, at the appropriate time, we'll make it available."

 

A lot of coaches like their offensive coordinator to also be the quarterbacks coach, where do you fall on that?

Singletary: "The people that we have, I believe in those people. Hopefully, as I said before, I think if we choose the right guy, we'll be able to work that out, whatever that is. So, as far as the offensive coordinator they want to have this guy do that, or whatever. Hopefully, we can work it, whatever it is. We'll work through it."

 

Are you prepared right now to address the subject of Alex Smith?

Singletary: "No. No. I am not."

 

Generally, what do you think this team needs personnel-wise?

Singletary: "Generally?"

 

What positions?

Singletary: "Definitely think we need to add another quarterback. I think we need to add an offensive lineman, guard or tackle. On the defensive side of the ball, we definitely need a pass rusher. You never have enough of those. So a couple of those guys would be great. Possibly a safety. Our guys have done a good job but going forward we may want to get a safety that has some range or what have you. So generally, to start with that's a good place to start right now."

 

Is Shaun Hill in a competition in your mind? Do you start fresh? What happens with him?

Singletary: "We'll see going forward. I'm not prepared to say right now whether Shaun Hill would go into training camp as a starter or what have you. It depends on what we do this offseason. Right now, whoever we bring in here, and I told Shaun Hill this: 'You're going to compete. You're going to compete.' If the situation is: 'Well, I should be the starter right off.' If you're the starter, you're going to start. If you're the starter, you're going to start. But we're going to compete. To me, I think competition is the greatest thing in the world so I feel that whoever the starter is going to be, they have to want to compete for it. It doesn't mean you have to go through the whole training camp but you have to compete for it."

 

Why not name Shaun Hill starter right now? You can always change your mind. Didn't he do enough over the past two months to deserve the title of starting quarterback at this point in time?

Singletary: "I want to say this: under the circumstances, everything that he did I really appreciated what he did. He did not surprise me in terms of what he did. That's why I wanted to go with him. I think Shaun Hill is a leader. I think all of the things we've talked about before, all of the things you've heard me say about Shaun Hill before, but the most important thing is that the best guy is our quarterback. We're not trying to look at situations and go, 'Well this guy here and he did a nice job here.' I want the best guys on our football team to play. If Shaun is going to be our starter, he's going to be the best quarterback that we have. But I'm not into making decisions right now and say, 'Shaun Hill.' Because... And I told Shaun this, and I told all of our players this, 'Anything that I tell you, I am telling you from my heart. Anything that I tell you I want you to take to the bank.' I don't ever want to tell a player something and then come back and say, 'You know what? I'm sorry I said that.' No, I'm not going to say I'm sorry. 'This is what I mean. What I tell you, that's exactly what I mean.' So if I'm saying that he's the starter right now and something happens this offseason where we get a guy that's better, I'm going to go into the season and play Shaun when I've got a guy that... I don't want to do that. And I don't think it's right to him. I don't think it's right to the club. I don't' think it's right to the players. I don't think it's right to anyone. So I don't want to get into making promises and making... just because somebody else says that I should. I want to do something because it's right. But right now, we're looking at winning football games and right now we want to get the best 11 guys on the field. Period. The best 11 guys. And I want those 11 guys to compete. Because we're going to have people here that can compete, and that makes us better. I don't want anyone going in thinking, 'You know what? I've got the job. I'm in great shape.' I want everybody to compete, and be ready to compete when they come. Because that's what I'm doing every day. Competing."

 

So you're saying your starting quarterback might not be on the roster right now?

Singletary: "You're right."

 

How much personnel work have you done in your career? Have you done some draft work as an assistant in the past? What input are you going to have on the draft this year?

Singletary: "I'm going to have a lot of input in the draft. Once again, it goes back to Scot and I having that understanding. I don't see Scot as above me, I don't see him as under me. He may be the guy that I report to. And I certainly know that Scot does not see me as above him or beneath him. I see us working together. That's the thing that we both talked about. Obviously the general manager has the responsibility of hiring or firing the head coach. That's his job just by title alone. Otherwise I'd be head coach and general manager. I understand that. But at the same time, we also know that in order for us to win, in order for us to be successful, we must, it is not an option, we must work together. If we don't work together we're dead. We're done. So when it comes to personnel decisions, I feel that if I'm sitting there and I'm looking at this guy and Scot's, 'Well hey, I really like that guy.' 'Really? Can I offer an opinion? Can I offer a different view?' To me, that's how we're going to get better. I'm not a yes man. I couldn't be one if I wanted to be. I can't be. But what I am, I am a person that really believes in communicating. I really believe in communicating wholeheartedly. If I don't teach my kids anything else, hopefully I teach them to be able to communicate their thoughts and feelings and be able to deal with the answer you get."

 

Over the last few offseasons, as an assistant head coach have you been in the room on draft day with everybody contributing?

Singletary: "Yes, I have been."

 

I know that after Patrick Willis was drafted Nolan brought you in to talk to us about him because he thought you played such a role in helping to scout him so to speak at the Senior Bowl. Are there other players on the roster that you drafted that you really pushed for?

Singletary: "No, and to be honest with you I didn't push for Patrick Willis either. I really didn't and I told Patrick this. I put the film on, I saw him and I thought there's a chance we may draft this guy? I was disappointed from what I saw the first time I saw him, I really was. I'm just being honest with you. Scot McCloughan said 'Mike, this guy is really talented, you really got to look at him again and I looked at him again and said 'Scot, you really like this guy?' He said 'Mike, I'm telling you. I know what you're saying but this guy is really good now, he's really going to be good.' So that year I learned something, but, what happened is right before the draft I began to understand and learn his history and I understood that his brother drowned before the season started and I understand all of the injuries that he had to work through. Then before the draft now I said 'you know what? I hope we get this guy because I had no idea the mount if adversity that he had  worked  through and if a guy can work through that kind of adversity there's something special about him and that's what I told Scot McCloughan before we drafted him but I didn't know the whole story and that's the value of personnel."

 

Mike you're a new head coach, you have a relatively inexperienced general manager, and a 27-year-old team president. Do you think that this organization would benefit from having some more NFL experience in the front office? Someone that you could turn to and ask advice and direction?

Singletary: "I feel like this and we've talked about this before I think when you talk about inexperience it certainly had its downsides. But so does experience. I've been in situations where I've been in  conversations where  guys say  I've been doing this for 30 years but you know what, it's been 30 years the wrong way. And so for me I think that with Scot. Scot may be young but I think he's beyond his years instead of knowing what the heck is going on there around the league and that's a testament to his father being in the business such a long time and I think Jed York is really busting his tail. The greatest thing that I can say about him is that he is a guy that is not telling you that I know. He is a guy that asks a lot of questions an there is wisdom in that. So I think between the three of us, yeah you can bring a guy in that's got all the experience in the world and run the big risk of really stifling all of the energy and the excitement and the ideas simply because he hasn't heard of it. Simply because it's outside of the box. Simply because it's outside of his comfort zone. I think that we will do just fine if we just stay together. I think our strength is in how we communicate with each other and how strong, the greater the communication, the greater the selflessness, the greater the team. So I'm excited about moving forward with the two of them and I think that the three of us, the sky is the limit. "

 

Are you feeling that, despite a couple late minute snafus against Miami and Arizona that this is a playoff team right now?

Singletary: "No I won't say that. I won't say that because I'm a realist. We're a playoff team when we're in the playoffs. A playoff team is not a team that is almost in the playoffs in my mind. We're not there I think that we have a lot of work to do to get there. I think that some teams may have overlooked us, they won't next year. So I think we have a lot of work to do and I would hate to say...I think it would be a very sad thing for me to say that we're basically a playoff team because if that's true then I think that we're all in trouble. We're not there, but we will be"

 

Mike, when having those discussions with the players a couple of days ago did any of the older players tell you or talk to you about perhaps they were going to retire or not be back next season?

Singletary: "Didn't hear that, no sir, did not."

 

When you start to sit down and view offensive coordinator candidates, will Scot McCloughan be part of those interviews?

Singletary: "Oh yes, absolutely."

 

Has that begun yet? Have you talked to anybody at this point...?

Singletary: "No, we're gathering a list and gathering all of the information that we can and trying to make sure that we have all the people on there to begin with and then we narrow that list as we go and get ready to make a decision."

 

Will that work evaluation take place tomorrow or Friday or will you pick it up next week? What's your immediate work schedule?

Singletary: "Today, tomorrow, the day after that, yeah. We're just working at it. To me right now in the offseason it's offseason for everybody else but we're on, we're moving."

 

Are you coming into work tomorrow?

Singletary: "Absolutely."

 

How are you celebrating the evening?

Singletary: "Lot of prayer, a lot of prayer."

 

* * *


40 Comments

| Leave a comment

Does the phrase "going forward" grate on anyone else....? Mike S. sure seems to like it, but I wish he'd use a different expression from time to time.

I really like the unabridged version. To me, Singletary is a really deep guy: this gets captured in the unabridged a bit better. By recollection, I seem to think that Nolan came off as more puffed up from unabridged interviews. Possibly the nature of journalism is a mitigating factor?

What do you think?

That Pat Willis/draft situation is very interesting.

If they could get Shanahan as OC it would instantly put the 49ers into the next level. He is the top choice, if he feels like working at OC for 2 or 3years. And if Singletary can have Shanahan looking over his shoulder. It's a long shot.
My guess is Brian Billick, because at the Ravens he had an average QB, but won with ball controll and a great defense. Singletary, being a defense guy, probably likes that model.
I'd rather go with a more West Coast style (including the Head Coach), but everyone loves Singletary, so, here we go again.

Thanks for this version Matt. Just another reason why you are the best football reporter in the nation. You have to care about your audience to give news in this much detail.

Just a thought. Singletary most likely would not have released Martz if he wasn't sure there was someone else out there that was better, and "signable". His potential OC may be on one of the teams still in he playoffs, and therefore he can not release his name, or negotiate any contract, until that team is out of the playoffs. With that scenario in mind, can anyone think of a potential candidate?

I listened to the press conference on KNBR and it did not impress me. I guess running a good conference doesn't have much bearing on being a good head coach yet for a guy who made his living in public speaking he did a poor job. He had made zero preparation and as a result his answers were confusing, contradictory and plain wrong. Does anyone really think Bill Walsh operated a run first offense? and how can all coaches come back when three were fired yesterday?

Most worrisome was his inability to articulate his offensive "philosophy". He clearly doesn't have one but like the art connoisseur that cannot describe what makes a great painting, Singletary will know an offense to his liking it when he sees it. In other words Singletary's going to interview a number of candidates and the one that sells his offensive ideas the best will get the job.

Unfortunately that's a classic sign of not knowing you're doing. In general, people that know what they are doing have no problem in describing how they do it. Jed 'n Scott 'n Mike have a combined zero minutes experience in hiring a coordinator and very little combined experience in running a franchise. This "we'll know it when we see it" approach is very hit and miss. Rather like Eddie's process of repeated hiring and firing until he stumbled across Walsh. That worked but how much by luck and how much by judgment?

Right now I'd guess the most likely outcome will be an OC that will please the crowd with his line of chat but will end up producing a rather boring and unsuccessful offense and both he and Mike will be fired next year about this time by an embarrassed Jed.

I sure hope not. But firing Martz without having something better lined up is not smart . Running the ball well in the 4th quarter did NOT win the last two games. In fact exactly the opposite, it was the unstoppable Martz passing attack that won them both.

I don't like the end of the year..my team is out and I am already looking forward to late July.
Reading what AP's take on the news conference is so different than what I read here. It's interesting to say the least. I just remember the 70's with Monty Clark and the years after Dick Nolan got fired, I felt like I was going back to the future… kids, that was an ugly time....Joe Thomas and garbage bins full of 49er paraphernalia, it was ugly..the last 7 years have reminded me of that. I hope the 49ers are on the way up again.
Mike Nolans first year, Horrible!!! Dennis Erickson just got side swiped, I thing Vince Lombardi would have had a tough time winning 2 games his last year. Those were unbearable teams to watch. Yet, we stick by them…and pour our hearts out to our gladiators every year win or lose.
Coach Sing however seems have that little extra something…..we will see if that little extra something pans out in Sept and Oct of 09, that’s where we have sucked we need a little rhythm going into late October November..So Going Forward….

Matt -- One of you in attendance should've played devil's advocate & asked Singletary the obvious: "Philosophically speaking, are you the anti-Martz insomuch favoring a game-management type of offense, a la Nolan/Alex Smith/Dilfer?

Bottom iine. the NFL is a QB League and we better get ourselves a blue chipper if we want to win a Super Bowl. Brady, Manning, Rothelisberger, except for rare occasions when teams have super human defenses you need Great QBs. We have neither a great defense nor a great QB. I like Coach alot and I am sure he understands we have to get better at QB

Oh my goodness his answer to the question about bringing in an experienced football guy was the perfect answer. The reason Silicon Valley is the powerhouse of innovation is that guys with energy and ideas got sick and tired of the experienced managers killing off any idea that seemed contrary to conventional wisdom. That was a hell of an answer.

Realfan49...I got a question for you. Have you even watched a Bill Belichick press conference. When he speaks you can fall asleep. A press conference is informational. Do you think Singletary is going to tip his hand to the press? The guy took the same team Nolan had (2-6) and made them better instantly (5-3).I dont count that Seattle game. That is all you need to see. He won 62% of his games. In a full season that is a 10-6 record. With a little more talent at the positions that he pointed out, Safety, pass rusher DE/OLB), guard, tackle and maybe QB we will be better.

Forget Shanny. he will not come here. He is not a long term solution. Here are some names. Rick Dennison, OC in Denver with Shanny. He is part of Jay Cutler's development. Has the zone run blocking, one cut and go system scheme. Dennison was also the o-line coach. Bill Musgrave. Matt Ryan's teacher. Pretty good developer of QBs. Though his success is better at QB coach than OC. Anyone got any other names. We have to think of guys that are either position coaches or former OCs that were good but the head coach got fired. Norm Chow is interesting but i definately dont like Linehan. Please no guys that still want to be head coaches. Like Martz.

Please that positive. I hate reading comments with negativity. Go 9ers!! We will win the west in 09.

BTW...hopefully with shanny fired...all the assistants got canned too. Dennison would be a great fit.

After hearing the press conference, I am not reassured. The 49ers still have the same organizational structure problem. When push comes to shove, who makes the football decisions? There is no proper chain of command. The Yorks have turned our beloved 49ers into Mike Brown's Bengals!

the other thing i would remind all the sing bashers out there who would love to see a "real genius" come in like holmgren or shanahan is that for the last few years, both of the the teams run by those two have been mediocre to awful....i would also note that a lot of their success was built around two HOF qb's............i don't need sing to wow me at a press conference, i just want the niners to win games, and if that is done by ripping off runs 6, 7, 8 yards at a pop until the other team proves it can stop you, then so be it......it would appear that sing has more than a few OC candidates that he feels would be better fits that martz was going to be.....one thing i've noticed is that many fans who are fed up with the reigning powers that be (mcclougan, sing, jed) act like somehow the public trust has been violated, and i would propose that no 49er coach in recent memory felt that sense of the team belonging to the fans more than sing has, certainly not smug-ass martz

Montana-to-Rice, you are an idiot. You never have anything smart to say. Montana is not comming back, neither is Rice. Let is go!! Jed York will fix this team. So will McCloughan and Singletary.

Chip Kelly, Oregon Ducks might not be a bad choice for offensive coordinator. Fits the mold Coach Singletary is looking for.

Kelvin, Singletary went 5-3 with Hill as QB and Martz as OC. My question is: what's so broken that we need to dump either or both of them?

I'm pretty sure the answer is that Jed doesn't like Martz so he has to go. Singletary's crappy answers just shows he hasn't got Jed's scripted answers down pat.

... and I'd still like to know why the Martz firing was leaked twice to the media and why Jed isn't doing anything to track down the culprit.

Scott said he knew who leaked the Nolan firing and said he couldn't do anything about it. Same story this time?

how do we know jed is doing nothing to get to the bottom of this?? because he didn't call you and tell you???.....i doubt he is, for all i know he leaked the info (maybe he leaked sing droppin trou too?)

regardless, i'm not a niner fan so i can argue with other people.....you have the right to dislike the direction you think the team is going, and i have the right to ignore you.....we can just continue to enjoy our rights

Kelvin - Take your insults and go someplace they would fit in, like a Raider blog. Firstly, RealFan49 has a point. Secondly, calling somebody an "idiot" for having a different point of view is pathetic.
Lastly, and most importantly, if you read the first 2 Q & A's again, you will see that Sing was talking out of his ass.
He totally contradicted what he said in the first answer. It's a good job we know he can coach. That was as bad as any Mike Nolan comments I've ever heard...and that guy was as non-sensical as it gets.

Having just read the whole transcript through again, I will say that Singletary comes across in a very similar fashion to Mike Nolan. Talks absolute drivel. Matt had to correct him, point out his contradictions and generally "persevere" with the Q&A. It was atrocious. It's a good thing we know the guy can coach, otherwise I'd be fearing the worst.

It's New Year's Eve! People are partying, making out, making love - and TJHooker is re-reading and grousing about a press conference at 3:46am. Seriously, TJ. I'm not getting a good picture of you here.

RealFan is right about what won the last two games in the stretch run. And Marco is spot on about QBs. Shaun Hill did a fine job last year and I would be comfortable about him starting next year, BUT since 1979 when the Steelers went to the passing game, EVERY SB champion had dynamics passing games (with exception of Ravens with one of the greatest defenses in history). You need a great or near great QB to be a consistent contender. After 42 years of watching the NFL, I've almost given up evaluating college talent as far as pro potential (Cassel throws NO TDs in college, starts no games at all, Alex Smith throws over 30 TDs in one year and is the first pick in the draft? Tim Couch is No.1, Tom Brady is low round pick, Kurt Warner, Jeff Garcia (one of only 6 QBs in NFL history to throw for 30 TDs two seasons in a row), Tony Romo - none of these three even DRAFTED. Having said that, Tim Tebow....big, strong, fast, GREAT leader, clutch, underrated arm...think a couple of years of development.....think Steve Young...wadday'all say, Faithful?

Hey Skeebers - leave TJ Hooker alone - I've made love to hundreds of women, and I go to bed early, don't party and I'm always thinking 49er football (this all and walking a lot keeps the body and mind in tip top shape and ready to go). Remember Diane Keaton asking Woody Allen in "Play it Again Sam" (filmed in SF by the way) why he was saying "slide" during sex. His answer was that he was thinking of Willie Mays - that it kept him going - HA!

Thank goodness this man is our coach. We have been blessed. He's the answer to lots of prayer, lots of prayer. We will run the ball. Brilliant! We will run a style more like Walsh's. Excellent! Coach will implement a clear and proven philosophy that pays respect to the organization's storied past, and we will reap the benefits. I have a lot more respect for Martz' system now than before the season, but, in the end, his approach is more novel than dominant. Martz did a great job this season, but letting him go was the right move. The one element of Martz' offense I think we absolutely need to carry over into the new regime is the use of quick timing patterns, especially slants. This was also a tenant of Walsh's offense. Those of us who remember the glory years, remember Jerry and JT racking up YAC on slants that went for 80 yard touchdowns. So excited about Coach Singletary. The football Gods have truly blessed us! Also, I'm with KezarMike, Tebow seems like one heck of a football player--the type of throwback that could thrive under Coach. Happy new year Niners fans!

Also, thanks for the awesome reporting, Matt. There's no better place for the 49ers news and analysis. It's much appreciated.

Schoolboys and weak men will not like Singletary. He is a my-way-or-the-highway kind of guy. Walsh was too for that matter.
He treats men like men. Eye to eye, here's what I think of you, here's what I expect of you, no bullbleep, no excuses. You give 100% effort or you hit the bricks.
Tough guys to work for. Winners. No patience with losers.

p.s. Loved the reporter's phishing question about 'wouldn't you like an experienced head to be able to get advice from?' Singletary is the kind of guy everyone else goes to for advice. He will be the dominant force in this organization.

Are there any opinions on Tom Rathman as a running back coach or some other assistant? I am not sure he has the experience to be an NFL OC yet, but he is a throwback player who should definitely be in line with the smash mouth running game Sing is looking for. It was playoff game that Tom ran Sing over bringing a touchdown in, was it not?

The one aspect I disagree with is Coach's apparent endorsement of the O Line. Time for actual Stats. see Football Outsiders. Yes they are a good rushing O Line, Also thank Frank Gore for his skills! But as far as pass protection goes they are still horrible.

Year Sacks Adj Rating
2005 48 sacks 31th
2006 36 sacks 24th
2007 55 sacks 32th
2008 55 sacks 31th led the League Again in total sacks

It's not even close, we have had the worst O Line at pass protection overall in the NFL the last four years. Maybe McCloughan needs to re-think his strategy

We all understood Martz would put pressure on pass protection, However we still continued to give up sacks even after the Singletary's chnageover and change in philosophy. At a lower rate , but still a rate worst than average. Playoffs? Get in the top 10 and then we can talk playoffs! The Stats don't lie and if they think our talent level for pass protection is anything but poor to fair, its delusional.

When our O-Line gives up half the amount of sacks I will be impressed!

Comment: The one aspect I disagree with is Coach's apparent endorsement of the O Line. . . . The Stats don't lie and if they think our talent level for pass protection is anything but poor to fair, its delusional. When our O-Line gives up half the amount of sacks I will be impressed!

My comment: Sacks are sacks. But sacks occur for a number of different reasons. When you looked at why the sacks occurred throughout the season, it was amazing how little the offensive line was actually to blame. After all, if a QB holds the ball too long, or a back fails to pick up a blitz or a blitzer comes off the edge unaccounted for, it's a sack. But there is nothing any offensive line could've done about it. Personally, I think the 49ers need an upgrade at right tackle. At every other spot, they're good enough to win. --Matt M.

In addition, Singletary did not endorse the OL for its pass protection, but its ability to block for the run. More runs, more play/action, less sacks.

RealFan wrote, "Most worrisome was his inability to articulate his offensive "philosophy"." That's incorrect.

One of the most frustrating aspects of the season was the inability of the 49ers to run the ball near the goal line. First and one and you don't score, something needs to change. While I appreciate Martz's passing system, apparently his offensive setup just doesn't give a team the ability to run the ball down the opposition's throat. Maybe it's the lack of a traditional bruiser at fullback, or something in the o-line blocking patterns - I don't know enough about the minutiae to have a clear understanding of the problem, but I don't think Martz has ever had a power running game - and that's something that an elite team needs. If you can run the ball successfully even when the opponent knows it's coming - as Singletary wants - you can win consistently even without a hall of fame QB.

So I think Singletary communicated very clearly the reason for bringing in a new OC. I'd have been happy to retain Martz and force him to adjust to a power running game - but Singletary's approach makes sense, too. Hopefully the new guy will be a strong passing schemer and not just a running game guru. I'm a big fan of the WCO style of Bill Walsh, which is not incompatible with a strong running game.

By the way, anyone who thinks that Singletary can sound like a Mike Nolan impersonator has got a screw loose. One eighty degrees.

Kelvin: I have to agree with TJ Hooker. Name-calling is inappropriate. I understand the temptation. Matt does such a great job of providing us with information that it makes me look forward to the comments producing a really interesting discussion. Then to read the incredibly stupid stuff RealFan and MontanatoRice (and sometimes Mr. hooker himself) throw in is really aggravating. In the meantime, we realy don't know what went into the Martz firing. Martz tried to adapt to Singletary's orders, but he had already made several decisions that kept the Niners out of the playoffs. He undervalued the fullback position, so we had no answer once Keasy went down. Although Martz tried to run, the ground game was less than scintilating. Furthermore, he misjudged both O'Sulivan and Hill and his going with the wrong starter was central to the 2-6 start. His panic at the end of the Arizona and Miami games turned likely wins into losses. So, while he did improve things over 2007, it is not hard to see why he has been fired before. However, those are just my observations. Behind closed doors, Singletary may have had more compelling reasons (such as Martz not committing to being here for a longer term than just one more year).

Comment: "Bottom line. the NFL is a QB League and we better get ourselves a blue chipper if we want to win a Super Bowl. Brady, Manning, Roethlisberger, except for rare occasions when teams have superhuman defenses you need Great QBs. We have neither a great defense nor a great QB. I like Coach a lot and I am sure he understands we have to get better at QB."

I don't see it as starkly as that. The last Super Bowl showed that a crushing defense can defeat the guy most people would rate (rightly or wrongly) the best QB in the league (and the Giants don't have the good Manning). The teams I think have the best shot at the SB this year (Panthers, Giants, Titans) don't have particularly gifted QBs, either. This is not to say QB play is unimportant, but it's part of a balance, and teams that are inconsistent or with glaring weaknesses (that can be exploited) on offense, defense, or special teams don't usually make the playoffs, much less the SB. Hope you don't mind that I corrected a few typos in your comment I posted above.

WOW! That's a SCOOP! Sing wants to RUN THE BALL...I have to say, I was intmimidated just by reading this! Sing has a unique intimidating demeanor, that even comes thru in his written words. Lets hope his offense has half of his firey intensity...Defenses BEWARE, we are gonna smash you in the face over and over and over again until you beg for MERCY!!
HAPPY NEW YEAR ALL, GO NINERS!

Of course blocking scheme, QB play, receivers, coaching, personnel, and time of possession all interact, but total sacks given applies to all teams and tends to level out, especially over a four year period.

Whatever the reasons, if we don't dramatically improve our O Line pass protection next year we won't be making the playoffs. Our number 10 pick could give us an excellent tackle.

Wilson, when a coach says he wants a run first offense just like Bill Walsh ran, to me that says he doesn't know what he's talking about. Especially when he goes on to say that he's not firing Martz because Martz is pass first but instead is firing him for offensive philosophy differences. Isn't that the same thing?

Anyhow putting that aside, you make an excellent point that the poor red zone offense almost certainly lost us the Miami game and maybe the playoffs. I agree with you that a power running game is essential to consistent red zone success. I think maybe the 49er problems had more to do with lack of a power back and dominant guard play than Martz but I could be wrong.

I would have done as you suggest, given Martz an opportunity to tell me how he was going to fix this for 2009. Only if he couldn't /wouldn't would I consider firing him. Martz is far from stupid and may well have come up with an excellent solution.

But as we know, the Martz firing was decided by Singletary, Jed and Scott in a closed room so we'll never know will we?

Talking of reasons why we missed the playoffs. I'd argue Jed was the major culprit. He decided to fire Nolan and instead of listening to Scott who said wait until the bye to not disturb preparations for the Seattle game, Jed leaked the firing and used that leak to hustle things along. I'd say that Nolan would have beaten Seattle at home just like he did away and Singletary could have then taken over and run the season from that point forward.

Wild unproductive speculation of course. But what else is there to do? Wouldn't it be soooo much nicer to be discussing Minnesota coming to the Stick on Saturday. Sigh.

From what I've seen the philosophy difference between Mike Martz and Mike Singletary is the distance in which the passes are thrown.

Martz is always looking for the long to momentum swinging completions.

Singletary seems to prefer the short to mid range completions seen in the basic West Coast offense.

Earlier in the year with JTO at the helm, Martz would continually call for long pass plays that required pocket time which resulted in sacks and qb fumbles.

When Singletary took over, we started to see more short to mid range passes which relied on receivers to gain yards after the catch, which worked for the latter half of the season.

But, you can't force a guy like Martz to do that for the entire season. When it comes down to a last minute, red zone play, Martz will go for the empty back field, 4 receiver formation as seen in the Miami game. That is what he is known for and what he will fall back on.

Leave a comment

Who is Matt?

Matt Maiocco is in his 14th year covering the 49ers. He has reported for The Press Democrat since 2000. He is a three-time winner of Pro Football Writers of America awards. Rotoworld.com ranked "Instant 49ers" as the No. 2 NFL team blog in the country in 2007. Maiocco has written two books, "Roger Craig's Tales from the 49ers Sideline" and "San Francisco 49ers: Where Have You Gone?" Matt can also be heard regularly on KNBR (680-AM) during the season. He is also been added this season as a regular guest on ESPN's "First Take."